They'll be useful for conquests or defense. Porcius • Both of the Roman Empires • 8 yr. Wrong settlement type [edit | edit source] Characters get a 75% penalty to income and levies in demesne settlements that do not match their government type. But nomadic holding doesn't provide any gold. Spears, and polearms in general, should make a comeback under "Two-handed" (I'd prefer the distinction between light/heavy, but semantics >. Dec 30, 2020 — Category: Ck2 tribal vs feudal. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. You're a feudal lord and he is a pesant, so he will always have a opinion hit towards you. Goverments are defined in the /common/governments folder, in the 00_government_types. (Obviously, IRL you can't just burn down a city and start building a castle on the ashes!The only holding type you have access to is "tribe" and there is a limit of one per county. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. These settlements should generally be given to a vassal of the correct type or to a courtier (who will automatically take on the correct type). It gives you a warning but it doesn't explain what are the problems with it, just to change it. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. Turns out I can't hand it out because it's a county capital. You get the same when you conquer territory in war with a CB that kicks out the previous owner (tribal subjugation, conquest or a holy war for example). what do I do if I want to retain control of it and get rid of that warning!To be fair Ck2 didn’t have that stuff for years. In general when you get the "Wrong Type of Holding" notification you should try and give it to the correct type of ruler. Either give it to an existing courtier or create a random new one out of thin air by right clicking on the holding and then "create new vassal". What do you choose to spend your money on? Weyird. All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos Workshop News Guides Reviews. I conquered Rome but had wrong hold type since the capital of the county was a temple. Yes, riding is better in many situation, but you may need desperately a hundred or two ducats just to create Empire title or smite some artifacts. I suggest that you give the county title to the Baron in that county. Now…By wrong type of holding I mean being a duke and holding a territory whose ruler should be a bishop. . By wrong type of holding I mean being a duke and holding a territory whose ruler should be a bishop. Jun 10, 2019. They pay lower taxes than cities and temples, but provide better levies, both in quality and quantity. Some county's capitals are city or bishop, so i get penalty for that. Therefore the system of "wrong type" is a little confusing according to. I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. Hi guys, I've seen a few notes on "wrong type of holding", but nothing seems to solve my problem. 22 votes, 144 comments. Jump to latest Follow Reply. Now, im not a CK2 novice, I know im not allowed cities or bishoprics but these are castles. Years later, my current king inherits the county and now I have the "Wrong type of Holding in Demesne" message. Afterwards, I got the "wrong type of holding" warning, and each holding in the three provinces. UncleCarp • 6 yr. I then. - When the mod is enabled, you (as well as the AI) can build unique castle upgrades in your capital holding. In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II which I do have. It is not worth it. Second, Bremen has both a Castle and a Temple. If these two aren't enough for you,. By the way, any time you personally hold a holding of the wrong type, the game will notify you in the same fashion it does when your ruler is not married or you. I have over 110 hours in Crusader Kings 2, and still have some questions. 1 GPM = 50 Levy. . Currently, the game doesnt really care that you are tribal when you conquer normal lands and simply gives you a standard "wrong holding" penalty or a "wrong government type. Tribes are a special case. Exothermically Eclectic Dec 30, 2013 @ 8:07pm. (this only applies to plains province though but these are some of the most common terrain types around in europe, a non-plains province will generally have a terrain unique eco building that pays back in ~40 years, closer to CK2 standards). #1. But I can't give it away. I clicked on the construct new holdings button, but it's still grayed out. Castles are the county seat for most counties; as such,. Anyone has any ideas?This is just a snapshot of the current state of the svn, it's playable on the latest version of CK2 and shouldn't have any major game-stopping bugs. . You are a feudal lord, so you need to hold a castle. I don't really know what's wrong. The Bishopry still remains the primary holding in the county which gives it 1 more building slot and it also retains the Duchy Building slot. Now, im not a CK2 novice, I know im not allowed cities or bishoprics but these are castles. Yorkie Jul 20, 2013 @ 5:02am. In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II which I do have. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Now, im not a CK2 novice, I know im not allowed cities or bishoprics but these are castles. The reason for this is the large penalty associated with owning a holding of the wrong type. They will get a relations penalty for wrong government type but will give you vassal troops like a normal feudal vassal. Masaoto. As Poland, I conquered the Pommeranian tribes to the north. . Anyone has any ideas?Crusader Kings. In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II which I do have. Second, Bremen has both a Castle and a Temple. These will give you stat increases, decisions and random events! - Don't worry if the upgrade has no immediate effect. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. To do this right click the barony in question and "create vassal". If it is the holding of a vassal, I don't think you can change their holding. Showing 1 - 3 of 3 comments. Then you can hand out the city to someone else, (preferably a mayor) and you'd have a de jure claim on the former Duke of Munster's territory or go after the Duke first and let him worry about the "wrong holding type" in Ormond. FAQ: Wrong Holding/Government Type. exe" -debug_mode) 2. To create the new vassal either nightclick a character and grant them the title, or click the Wrong Type of Holding Pop-Up and rightclick the Holding on the bottom left and press on Create New Vassal. Ok so I'm completely new to CK2, never played the original. In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II which I do have. These will give you stat increases, decisions and random events! - Don't worry if the upgrade has no immediate effect. As Poland, I conquered the Pommeranian tribes to the north. If you want to get rid of this hit, change it to a county. I hold Leicester as Earl. If a character is of the wrong caste, they cannot be granted the holding. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. Can't construct new holding. In the long run I agree that you should revoke and replace--having the constant negative opinion penalty from wrong government type is unbearable--just BE CAREFUL of when you do it. . Wrong holding just eat money but characters will actually accumulate wealth and build stuff here, btw keeping taxes low you speed up development. Mastur Ch33f Sep 19, 2020 @ 1:42am. Just now, I finished constructing a new city in the county where my ruler resides. as you cannot build multiple tribal holdings in one county and get crippling penalties for wrong holding type. Game Version: 1. This includes city holdings. In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II. May 6, 2013 @ 2:55pm. I hold Leicester as Earl. I was playing as. Crusader Kings II 69786 Bug Reports 19704 User Modifications 10571 Suggestions 5969 Tech. But I can't give it away. Frustratingly, clicking on the notifier takes me to a "Realm" window which. Is it possible to change this city into a castle so the wrong holding type penalty will disappear?im playing a game, i beat a muslim place on a holy war and take it over, i now have a wrong type of holding warning. My income in that province increased greatly. And since I'm a count, I can't have count vassals, so. What do you choose to spend your money on? Weyird. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. . . . Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. You can see it has a city as county capital but it's held by a duke (noble) so it's the wrong type of holding. These control whether or not the 'Recently Conquered' and 'New Administration' holding modifiers are set on victory. 3 more GPM, but 150 less Levy. Capitals change when the Count/Prince-Bishop/Lord Mayor has direct control of a holding of his own type. You can conquer counties that were improved by feudal characters, and you'll get mayors and priests as vassals if. Or you can select the city and click on the button to have the game choose a mayor for you. Hi guys so I am rather new to CK, I am really enjoying ck3 however I have one thing I cant figure out what to do. ) New: - Added three river crossings in Black Marsh. Always something to learn as they say. So, to. Holdings can be Castles, Cities, or Temples. Not to mention that holding the wrong holding type means you are responsible for uphgrading. This includes Cities of Wonders 2, which we've previously featured and introduces a fourth type of holding – the metropolis. . Some of them are pretty easy to spot. Tribalism is an early form of government, and one of three playable non-feudal government types in CK2 (the other two being merchant republics and nomadism . #9. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without penalty, but can easily build new tribes in conquered territory; they can also build temples. May 6, 2013 @ 2:55pm. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. Why is it bad to govern cities directly? I am guessing it is bad since I got the message warning me. Jun 9, 2019. Aug 28, 2013. But you can also see there is a castle in this county: Image 3. So im still not understanding this right. You get the same when you conquer territory in war with a CB that kicks out the previous owner (tribal subjugation, conquest or a holy war for example). Anyway, got a new problem that I can't seem to work out, hope you guys can help. Oh my bad, sorry! I edited the post because a typo. 'Wrong Type of Holding' = SO CONFUSED Clan leader = Jarl, Earl and Baron of Area A. When that happens, the AI will move the capital and then generally appoint a new baron-level holder to the former capital. powered by Peatix : More than a ticket. As a King can only hold two Duchies without a large opinion penalty from. what do I do if I want to retain control of it and get rid of that warning!So, i wish to hold a city holding along with my original county holding (castle) but yet I cannot as its the “wrong holding type”, I do not wish to give it to some lowly baron, instead i wish to have it for my self and by god am i going to get it and keep it for myself, so, is there anyway in the game files the adjust the “wrong holding type” sittings?Government type is the form of government that a character lives under or rules by. But I can't give it away. Holdings produce all levies and taxes, and are thus important, yet easily ignored. Tribals can raid and have concubines. Is it possible to change this city into a castle. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. So I was playing the demo earlier and an 'alert button' popped up saying that a few of my provinces were the wrong type of holding in my demesne. I'm playing the Amalfi merchant republic and have expanded to hold the republic of Sicily, there are a few of my vassals that have the wrong government type modifier which is a bit of a downer so I'm wondering, how do I fix this?Destroying holdings won't overpass the balance issue of having at least 1 of each type of holding in every province: it will only free a holding slot. So im still not understanding this right. I fabricated a claim and captured the county, usurping the prince-bishop. Anyone has any ideas?im playing a game, i beat a muslim place on a holy war and take it over, i now have a wrong type of holding warning. I conquered Rome but had wrong hold type since the capital of the county was a temple. last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god for autosave. Every county has at least one holding, and most have three. . Holdings can be Castles, Cities, or Temples. As you can see, Temples make 0. anyway. More info available in _governments. There are three types of holdings. Okay, so I was playing as the Most Serene Doge of Genoa. So, I'm the king of England. Edit: I found that I could just 'give landed title' away the Fylkja title and that 'fixed' it, but still. >). Now, im not a CK2 novice, I know im not allowed cities or bishoprics but these are castles. 3 System - bug is non-system related Platform - Steam Mods - none Severity - Major, all Tribal Holdings useless Description - According to the wiki: 'If a Feudal or Clan ruler owns a Tribe it will gain no taxes or levies from but will have the option to turn it into a Castle at the cost of 500. Host #1 appears out of nowhere. And here CK2 handled cities much better - city vassals gave a lot of extra money at the expense of some relation penalty. I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. Just had a change of leaders, for some reason one of my demenses changed from the castle (barony) being the main title, to a city. Each form of government has preferred and allowed settlements, and will get 'Wrong government type' (-75 levies and income) penalty while holding other types of settlements directly. Early game they're cheap but get pricey quick. You can change the primary holding type by granting the county title to a baron/mayor/bishop character in that county. What Is The Best Way To Fix The Holder Is Wrong Holding Type In Crusader Kings 2 Use Cheat Codes. Search for the ID. - Added title history commands 'name', 'adjective', 'reset_name' and 'reset_adjective'. So im still not understanding this right. . It depends on what type of building it is as well, since you're tribal and it's a wrong holding I'm guessing it's a castle that requires feudal government. The only place that was practical to exand into at the start was a county controlled by a prince-bishop. However, my problem is that apparently every holding in England is of the wrong type. Holy war - usurp the entire target duchy. Anyone has any ideas?So, I'm the king of England. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. - Added links to. Holding multiple castles in a single county is better than only holding one castle in a single county, but worse than holding a single castle in multiple counties. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. Thus, after winning the war, I gained the County to my personal demesne, meaning that I now owned the Capital settlement, in. Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without. You can hold them but it greatly reduces the. There are three types of holdings: Baronies: Focus on troops. As the title says, is it possible to create a new type. In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II which I do have. So im still not understanding this right. . Hello everyone ! I am coming to this forum today because I have a little question about modding CK2. Barons are affected by feudal ta, mayors are. last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god for autosave. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Therefore, every count who holds this city gets a wrong holding type penalty of -30 (!) with me being a lord. In the long run I agree that you should revoke and replace--having the constant negative o. To start with, the basics are fairly simple. Cities: Focus on tax. ago. There are 3 character types - feudal, burgher, and bishop. Thread starter Morik; Start date Mar 12, 2014; Jump to latest Follow Reply. First, Hamburg just has a city. By Arqam 2023-05-14 2023-05-14 ShareYes, you should in theory be able to convert a Metropolis holding to whatever other holding type you want. Xihu. And you can not rule over cities, as this would make you an republic ruler, something the player cant be. PK SPACE JAM. anyway. Horemvore Sep 19, 2020 @ 12:45am. anyway. Modding - Create new type of holding. Aug 12, 2015. Is there any was to change the county capital to a barony? Does it hurt me to hold a county that is the wrong type of holding?So im still not understanding this right. It's just that they pay more if they like you ;D. When revoking a title for a wrong type of holding (bishopric or city), you lose all troops in those holdings, and they don't reinforce, => no garrison or levy. I got this message when I revoked the title of major of Sigtuna (a city) from an underling. And you can not rule over cities, as this would make you an republic ruler, something the player cant be. I'm the Count of Northumbria, and have recently won the title of County Durham as well after a succesful war. Oh, yes - you also get money from them. I hold Leicester as Earl. Im confused what the message "Wrong type of holding in demense" means. Each form of government has preferred and allowed settlements, and will get "Wrong government type" (-75% levies and income) penalty while holding other types of settlements directly. I have managed to give it away, thanks for the tip. Wrong type of holding in demesne. Now, im not a CK2 novice, I know im not allowed cities or bishoprics but these are castles. im playing a game, i beat a muslim place on a holy war and take it over, i now have a wrong type of holding warning. Anyone has any ideas?Yorkie Jul 20, 2013 @ 5:02am. Hi so I started in the earliest playthrough as the count of austria (well what will someday be austria i hope) I have a bishopric holding that isn't giving me anything (wrong holding) so i saved up 500+ ducets to guild a fort. My income in that province increased greatly. Changes: - Changed Pale Pass Holy Site for Court of Dawn's Beauty to Rhalta. Sounds like you're tribal and the holding is feudal. Bought the game during the summer sale and have 20 hours in, feeling like I'm starting to get the hang of things, but still so many questions. After all, value of a tribal holding depends solely on amount of empty space and bonuses this space provides. Generally giving away to someone can alleviate the problem. Business, Economics, and Finance. 8/11/2019 A demesne is a character's collection of personal holdings. 3 System - bug is non-system related Platform - Steam Mods - none Severity - Major, all Tribal Holdings useless Description - According to the wiki: 'If a Feudal or Clan ruler owns a Tribe it will gain no taxes or levies from but will have the option to. They pay the most taxes, and once upgraded give numerous levies, but have a lower fort level than castles and their levies consist more of the lighter soldier types than both castles and temples. However, my problem is that apparently every holding in England is of the wrong type. Look for the ID of the barony you want to change (you have to start the game in debug mode and then hover over the barony on the map and the ID is in purple) Open the gamestate. First, Hamburg just has a city. The wrong holding penalty therefore comes up when you are directly in charge of a city or church. Crusader Kings. By wrong type of holding I mean being a duke and holding a territory whose ruler should be a bishop. Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. It would be a far better way of doing it. Written by NewbieOne. It is not worth it. I know there's an Elder Kings subreddit, but figure this was a general mechanic and wanted to get the info. Conversely, having low opinion may trigger the character to be more hostile, joining factions or plots against the other. exe" -debug_mode) 2. Im confused what the message "Wrong type of holding in demense" means. If you give it to a vasall you will get at least 45/50% or more percent of the base income. At the moment, my count appears as ruler of the county, but I'm barely collecting any tax - as apparently it's the wrong type of. Hell Ormond might even decide that your war is the perfect time to fight a war of independence and the O'Brien's. Jump to latest Follow Reply. . My. If Hindu, be sure to match the character's caste with the holding type. Bring up the console command box by pressing the tilde key (~). So, I'm the king of England. Is it impossible to change Holding Type?This is the second part of a four-part (I, IIa, IIb, III, IV) series examining the historical assumptions of the popular historical grand strategy game Crusader Kings III, by Paradox Interactive. I've noticed that the castle garrison is not refilling - is that just because of the New Administration penalty, or is garrison regeneration also being affected by the Wrong Holding Type penalty?Have a revolt risk modifier until the culture shift to norse and then have the holding change to a tribe rather than a castle. But nomadic holding doesn't provide any gold anyway and does provide levies only if you stack modifiers really high, so it is not a problem. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. This works well, especially in coastal duchies (extra buildings for cities basically double their tax income). Im playing Jylland, i took Sjaelland easily and then took Mercia through the event which prepares an invasion. P1: Fixing the holder’s wrong holding type in Crusader Kings 2 involves modifying the game’s saved file. 2. #5. Wrong Type Of Holding In Demesne; Some of them are pretty easy to spot. Folks, another clueless newbie question: in my current game, I am getting more cash than I'm used to, so I've been improving cities in my demesne left and right. I am playing with CK2+ mod and ruler designer - not sure if that matters in this situation. However, my problem is that apparently every holding in England is of the wrong type. The issue isn't that i have tribal vassals, it's that i have Feudal vassals (both direct and non direct) holding tribal lands, and a bunch of them show "wrong type of holding" when i click on the holding screen. . I'm playing a small count in Germany (Altmark), and after acquiring Mecklenburg from the pagans I am faced with various problems. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Model wise long boats and cogs exist, too. There are three types of holdings: Baronies: Focus on troops. It is very misleading. Post in it to add your new mods or updates. Each County has provinces that can be used to build a Holding. For that to happen, he has to own both the capital and a holding of his preferred type. I'm a Norse Tribal Jarl, and captured a feudal county. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Being of your religion reduces the revolt risk of that vassal by 25%, that means an opinion of -25 with a vassal is a 0% revolt risk instead of 25%. , I imprison/banish a mayor (as a king with one county), and take possession of his title. And even better, almost all of these have added some sort of hidden easter egg. normally if you have the resources then you can replace it, exept things you cant build due to religion or Innovation. 2)ship tech increase galley troop etc carrly limit ? if its not then what does it increase ? Kaza: Gives you more ships of your holding. Not sure what to do with it. Anyways, I'm playing my first game as the Ua Briain dynasty in Ireland. ck3 with notepad++. Sep 9, 2020. . last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god for autosave. Am I supposed to spend a bunch of money to upgrade the tribe into a castle? I think that "wrong holding type" actually means "wrong government" You would get a Malus to income and levies from that holding, 75% Malus to both i think. Neither government can hold cities, which, barring mods, can only be held by republics. But I can't give it away. Got in and discovered what's happened. Most rulers can only hold one type (the exception being Muslim lords can have mosques as well as castles, and only get the penalty for cities). I clicked on the construct new holdings button, but it's still grayed out. The capital of a province could change from a castle to a city in the same province if you have both in your demesne. Im playing Jylland, i took Sjaelland easily and then took Mercia through the event which prepares an invasion. You can hold castles without penalty. I hold Leicester as Earl. I'm playing as a High Chief in Ireland. You can basically hand the title to any landable character in your court. They pay the most taxes, and once upgraded give numerous levies, but have a lower fort level than castles and their levies consist more of the lighter soldier types than both castles and temples. Don't get me wrong, I feel your frustration, but when you consider how many variables are being checked at any given time in-game, it's not all that surprising how. Castles are holdings held primarily by feudal lords. I'm told by my Situation report that I have holdings of the wrong type for my government, making them worthless as sources of tax and levies. Whether you become feudal or clan depends on whether you're muslim or not. You can only do this to your holdings which are feudal. I don't want to change my capital county, but the capital holding in the county. By Arqam 2023-05-14 2023-05-14 ShareIm playing Jylland, i took Sjaelland easily and then took Mercia through the event which prepares an invasion. . is of type baron and thus makes the holding completely worthless (no levie, no tax income etc) Of course I mean, is there a way to fix. Jump to latest Follow Reply. So im still not understanding this right. . Imagine playing a schemer with a "Spy Network" landless holding who builds buildings that expand his intrigue options. Hi so I started in the earliest playthrough as the count of austria (well what will someday be austria i hope) I have a bishopric holding that isn't giving me anything (wrong holding) so i saved up 500+ ducets to guild a fort. Each form of government has preferred and allowed settlements, and will get "Wrong government type" (-75% levies and income) penalty while holding other types of settlements directly. I. So im still not understanding this right. Dear CK2 players, Somehow one of my county capitals is a city. #1. primary_building = tribe_01 buildingsA clever method (if you have the spare 500 gold) is: once you conquer a tribal holding, or duchy ideally, you pay the 500 to convert one of the holdings and give it to an unlanded character. last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god for autosave. A character is affected by your levy and taxation laws based on their type. All the empty baronies are useless to tribal rulers. By wrong type of holding I mean being a duke and holding a territory whose ruler should be a bishop. What exactly does this mean?The change log for 1. If these two aren't enough for you,. However a castle holding will never change into a city holding as you asked in your question. believe it or not, the closest I came was in a ridiculously overly combat balanced character who stalled out at 2 counties left before he got into the "I'm so old I. Aug 12, 2015. 403K subscribers in the CrusaderKings community.